This week’s focus article sits at one of my favorite intersections in the learning sciences: memory, metacognition, effective studying, and attention. It takes a close look at prequestioning, the seemingly simple act of trying to answer a few questions about material you’re about to read - either questions you come up with yourself, or questions an instructor presents to you.
As we’ll see, this one simple act has solidly positive effects on retention for that material. Even better, those benefits are surprisingly durable, holding up through some fairly major changes in how the reader goes about the prequestioning process. That makes it a versatile and worthwhile learning strategy, according to the authors. I concur, being a fan of prequestioning myself.
A few patterns in the findings suggest that prequestioning works, at least in part, through attentional mechanisms - namely, by helping direct readers’ focus to the most germane information as they work their way through a text. Readers who’ve followed my work for a while know that this attention-memory-learning connection is one I care a lot about. Attention has shown up prominently in all three of the books I’ve written. The new one coming out in early 2027 focuses exclusively on this powerful, complicated, and enigmatic aspect of human cognition: The Attention Spectrum: How Attention Really Works and How to Make It Work for You. Keep an eye on future issues of R3 or enter your email here to sign up to receive updates from me as the publication date approaches.
In a similar vein, you might want to check out this episode of the How to Touch Grass podcast that I recorded with The Atlantic. The topic is “why bother learning anything when AI can do it for you,” with a pretty freewheeling discussion of what happens when we try to learn hard things even when we don’t have to.
Citation:
Rivers, M. L., Berdelis, A. J., Pan, S. C., & Tauber, S. K. (2026). Does covert prequestioning enhance learning? Implications for the roles of attention and retrieval in the prequestioning effect. Applied Cognitive Psychology. 40:e70165.
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.70165
Paywall or Open:
Paywall
Summary
This study tested whether prequestioning enhances retention of to-be-read material when learners answer the questions mentally rather than typing out responses. Across two experiments, undergraduate students read expository text passages after either answering prequestions overtly, answering them covertly, or reading statements about what they were about to learn. Both overt and covert prequestioning improved performance on later multiple-choice tests. Reading learning objectives also improved performance. The authors interpret this pattern as evidence that prequestioning may work partly by directing attention to relevant material, not only by engaging readers in retrieval.
Research Questions
Does covert prequestioning - mentally answering questions before reading - improve later learning from text?
Is covert prequestioning as effective as overt prequestioning, where learners type out their answers?
Are the benefits of prequestioning best explained by retrieval, attention, or some combination of both?
(Experiment 2) Does prequestioning outperform reading statements that preview the same key information?
Sample
Undergraduate students at a university in the southwestern United States. Experiment 1: N= 165, ages 16 to 39, mean age 19.70, 72.7% women, 26.1% men, and 1.2% gender diverse. Experiment 2: N=315, ages 18 to 40, mean age 19.55, 81.3% women and 18.7% men.
Method/Design
Across two experiments, participants read two short expository passages, one about Yellowstone National Park and one about Saturn. For one passage, they completed a pre-reading activity; for the other, they simply read the passage, which served as the read-only control.
Participants were randomly assigned to one of two prequestioning groups. In the overt prequestioning group, they typed answers to short-answer questions before reading. In the covert prequestioning group, they silently generated answers without typing them. After each passage, participants completed a five-minute distractor task, then took a 20-item multiple-choice test. For the prequestioned passage, some test items were the same as the prequestions, while others were related but had not been directly asked beforehand.
Experiment 2 used the same basic procedure, but added a condition where participants read a statement describing the learning objectives, i.e., what readers were supposed to get out of the passage, without being asked to answer questions. Experiment 2 also asked participants to report what they remembered doing mentally during the pre-reading activity.
Key Findings
Both overt and covert prequestioning improved performance on later test questions that directly matched the prequestions. Covert prequestioning was generally as effective as overt prequestioning, despite taking less time.
Benefits were strongest for “same” questions, meaning those directly asked before reading. Benefits were smaller and less consistent for test questions that were related but not identical to the prequestions.
In Experiment 2, reading preview statements produced similar effects as prequestioning. This pattern suggests that prequestioning may work partly by directing attention to important information in the upcoming text, not only by prompting retrieval attempts.
Students also perceived the strategy as useful: 69% in Experiment 1 and 79% in Experiment 2 rated the pre-reading activities as more effective than reading alone.
Choice Quote from the Article
Overall, this research expands our understanding of the PE [prequestioning effect] by showing that covert prequestioning (mentally answering questions without written responses) can be as effective as overt responding. Our findings suggest that multiple cognitive mechanisms, such as retrieval, prior knowledge activation, and attentional focus, may work in tandem, with their relative contributions depending on task demands and learner strategies. Given its flexibility and ease of implementation, prequestioning remains a promising tool for promoting deeper learning across diverse educational contexts.
Why it Matters
I find it intriguing, and practically encouraging, that readers do not have to fill out anything formal to benefit from prequestioning. Merely thinking through prequestions in the right way can improve retention later on. This means that you, the instructor, do not have to set up a structured quiz, collect answers, or grade anything for prequestioning to work. Anything that gets students engaged in thinking purposefully about what they are about to read might be enough.
That makes prequestioning one of the most practical pieces of advice we can offer to students: set expectations and goals before starting to read, and never dive into a complex reading cold. (I say this as someone who frequently has to remind herself of these exact points, including when I am reading focus articles for this newsletter.)
This process resembles, but is distinct from, retrieval practice. Overt retrieval practice would be something like requiring students to answer questions over material they have just read before allowing them to continue. Covert retrieval practice would be more like asking them to think through those answers silently. As the authors explain, previous research on retrieval practice has generally shown that overt retrieval produces stronger benefits than covert retrieval, although covert retrieval can still outperform simple restudying/rereading or no review at all.
Prequestioning is also distinctive because students are trying to answer before they have studied the material - essentially, guessing about things they don’t know, which on the face of it might seem rather useless. But in fact, guessing may prime readers to pick up on the correct information when they do eventually encounter it, creating a gap to fill and a reason to notice the answer.
This is also a useful reminder about “desirable difficulties.” It is easy to run away with that concept and assume that more effort is always better. But here, the more effortful version - typing out answers - was not reliably better than the less effortful approach. The added friction of overt responding may be worthwhile when instructors need accountability or want to assess what students know going in, but it does not appear to be the active ingredient in this case.
Finally, I appreciated the careful dissection of possible mechanisms here: retrieval, attention, exposure to relevant information, transfer-appropriate processing, and depth of processing all come into play. The findings do not give us a single tidy explanation as far as these explanatory mechanisms, but it’s reassuring to think that at least one, and maybe more, back up the claim that prequestioning is a good study move.
Limitations, Caveats, and Nagging Questions
The authors frame the findings almost exclusively in terms of attention and retrieval, which makes sense given the literature they are building on. But I can also imagine that affective and motivational factors - curiosity, in particular - might come into play. At least from my own perspective as an enthusiastic lifelong fan of nonfiction, filling gaps and resolving mysteries sets us up not just to remember facts, but to find intellectual joy. If prequestioning could help link those cognitive and emotional sides of reading, so much the better.
From a practical standpoint, I also wondered about times when overt prequestioning might still be preferable to covert. If students are mature, motivated, and practiced readers, covert prequestioning might be perfectly effective. But if they are not, asking them to silently think through prequestions may be too easy to do superficially or not at all. In those cases, requiring overt responses may still be useful, not because writing is inherently better for learning, but because it makes the activity visible and helps ensure students actually do the work.
There may also be a rich-get-richer dynamic. Students who already know how to slow down, think ahead, and use prequestions strategically may be the ones most likely to benefit from a covert version of the activity. Students who most need the support may need more structure, at least at first.
It is also worth noting that the passages in this study were fairly short, at about 1100 words each. There is no obvious reason the same principles would not apply to longer texts, such as an 8000-word book chapter, but I would be cautious about simply giving students a list of prequestions at the beginning and having them dive in to the whole thing. For longer works, I suspect the safer strategy would be to pair a small set of big-picture prequestions at the start with section-by-section prequestions along the way.
Another caveat is that students did not generate the questions themselves; the questions were provided. My intuition is that student-generated prequestions, in the spirit of strategies like SQ4R, could work similarly or even better once students know what they are doing.
Finally, the attention-versus-retrieval angle is thought-provoking, and frankly validating for those of us who keep emphasizing the attention-memory-learning connection. But the study did not directly measure attention while students read, as the authors readily acknowledge. Future studies using eye tracking, think-aloud protocols, or other process-tracing methods could give a more precise picture of how prequestions change what readers actually attend to.
If you liked this article, you might also appreciate:
Callender, A. A., & McDaniel, M. A. (2009). The limited benefits of rereading educational texts. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 34(1), 30–41. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2008.07.001
Cohn, J. (2021). Skim, dive, surface: Teaching digital reading. West Virginia University Press.
McCarthy, K. S., & Hinze, S. R. (2025). Stage 2 Registered Report — You’ve got some explaining to do: Effects of explanation prompts on science text comprehension. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 39:e70093. https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.70093
McDaniel, M. A., Howard, D. C., & Einstein, G. O. (2009). The read-recite-review study strategy: Effective and portable. Psychological Science, 20(4), 516–522. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2009.02325.x
Nguyen, K. & McDaniel, M. (2014). Potent techniques to improve learning from text. In Benassi, V. A., Overson, C. E., & Hakala, C. M. (Eds.), Applying science of learning in education: Infusing psychological science into the curriculum. Society for the Teaching of Psychology, 37(1), 303.
Pan, S. C., Schweppe, J., Teo, A. Z. J., Indrajaya, A., & Wenzel, N. (2025). Using ChatGPT-generated prequestions to improve memory and text comprehension. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition. Advance online publication. https://dx.doi.org/10.1037/mac0000254
File under: prequestioning, SQ4R, reading, attention, memory


In L2 literature classes I see the same pattern: a 60-second covert prequestion (“which two moves on the page would make this claim false?”) often does more than a written warm-up. Your point that attention-routing can share credit with retrieval matches what happens when students stop hunting for a theme-label and start scanning for operations. Have you seen covert prequestions transfer as cleanly to multimodal texts (image + caption) as to straight exposition?
I appreciated your reminder to prequestion for myself, especially before I read news reports. It's an attention that allows me to concentrate more clearly on what I'm about to read while putting my judgments and opinions on hold.
And thank you for 'intellectual joy,' which gives me language to describe so well that feeling when a 'mystery' is solved and my curiosity is sated.